Recipe variations: Mint S'mores = Substitute chocolate covered mint cookies for the crackers. Peanut Butter S'mores = Substitute chocolate covered peanut butter cups for the candy bars. Striped S'mores = Substitute chocolate striped cookies for the graham crackers Rainy Day S'mores = Substitute marshmallow cream for the toasted marshmallows. Spread marshmallow creme on cracker tops. Scotchie S'mores = Substitute chocolate graham crackers for the regular graham crackers. drizzle butterscotch ice cream topping over the candy bar before adding marshmallow.